Thursday, August 19, 2010

A Death That Brings Life


Dear Parish Faithful,

A bit more on the Dormition of the Theotokos from St. John of Damascus (+749):

Today the treasury of life, the abyss of grace (I do not know how I can say these things with my bold, fearless lips!) is wrapped in a death that brings life. Undaunted, she draws near to death, having given birth to death's destroyer - if one may call her departure from the world, so full of holiness and life, a death at all. For how could she, who brimmed over with true life for all, ever become subject to death's power? Still, she yields to the law established by her own Son, and as a daughter of the old Adam she undergoes the ancestral trial, since even her Son, life itself, did not refuse it. But as Mother of the living God, it is also right that she should be brought into his presence. For if God was concerned "lest the first human being reached out his hand and take from the tree of life and eat, and live forever ..." (Gen. 3:21), how can she, who has received the life that knows no beginning or ending, the life free from the boundaries of both birth and death, not live herself for endless ages?

Let us praise her, then, today with sacred songs, we who are privileged to be called and to be the people of Christ. Let us honor her with an all-night assembly. Let us delight in her holiness of soul and body; after all, she is truly, after God, the holiest of all beings, for like always delights in like! Let us do her homage by or mercy and our compassion for the poor. For if God is honored by nothing so much as by mercy, who can deny that his mother is glorified, too, by the same thing? She has opened to us the unspeakable depth of God's love for us!

St. John of Damascus, Homily II on the Dormition, 2, 16.



Fr. Steven

Wednesday, August 18, 2010

The Paschal Death of the Theotokos


Dear Parish Faithful,

As we continue to celebrate the Dormition of the Theotokos, I would like to share some theological reflection from the Church Fathers on the meaning of the Feast. SVS Press has published a wonderful book, On the Dormition of Mary - Early Patristic Homilies. These works are translated by Brian E. Daly, almost all for the first time into English. The homilies included in this volume come from the early 6th - 9th c. This was the earlier part of the Byzantine Era of the Church, and these homilies are characterized by the lofty rhetoric of that period's homiletic literature. Perhaps the greatest homilist of that era was St. John of Damascus (+749), one of the great theologians in the history of the Church. St. John combines profound theological insight with a highly-developed grasp and use of the rules of rhetoric. Perhaps a mere sampling of a passage or two, may convey something of his gift as theologian and orator:

Oh, see how the source of life is carried over into life, through the midst of death! See how the one who overcame the defining limits of nature in her childbearing now gives way to those same limits, and submits her unsullied body to death! It was only right for that body to "lay aside what is mortal and put on immortality" (I Cor. 15:53), since the Lord of nature himself did not refuse the test of death. He died in the flesh, and by that death destroyed death, bestowed incorruptibility on corrupt nature, and made death the source of resurrection. See how the maker of all things receives into his own hands her holy soul, now separated from that tabernacle that received God. He rightly honors her who was by nature his handmaid, but whom by his saving plan he made to be his mother, in the unfathomable ocean of his love for humanity. For he truly became flesh, and did not feign his incarnation!

... Therefore I will not call your holy passing [from this world] a death, but rather a falling-asleep, a parting, or - more properly speaking - a homecoming. For when you parted from the things of the body, you went to make your dwelling among greater things.

St. John of Damascus, Homily I, 10.


Another great homilist from that era, one would can "rival" St. John of Damascus, is St. Andrew of Crete (+740) and author of the celebrated Great Canon of Repentance. St. Andrew also beautifully extols the death of the Theotokos as a "paschal death" that reveals the saving fruits of Christ's own death and resurrection:

Indeed, if I must speak the truth, the death that is natural to the human race even reached as far as Mary: not that it held her captive as it holds us, or that it overcame her - far from it! But it touched her enough to let her experience that sleep that is for us, if I may put it this way, a kind of ecstatic movement towards the things we only hope for during this life, a passage that leads us on towards transformation into a state like that of God. ... She fell into a natural sleep and tasted death, but did not remain held by it; she simply followed the laws of nature and fulfilled God's plan, which the Providence that guides all things laid down for us from the beginning. Her role, surely, was to show us clearly the way she has moved through the transformation from a corruptible state to an incorruptible one - something that is only thinkable if a natural dissolution of these elements of our body should take place first, and if then the life that has melted away should be forged anew.

St. Andrew of Crete, Homily II, 4.



Fr. Steven

Monday, August 16, 2010

Thoughts on The Ground Zero Mosque


Bus Ads running in NYC, questioning the proposed Ground Zero Mosque,
a visual reminder of the polarization discussed below.

Dear Parish Faithful,

At least into the foreseeable future, there will always be a great deal of polarization when assessing the nature of Islam, and the role that Islam and Muslims will assume in the United States. That will be the undying legacy of the infamy of the Muslim terrorist attacks of 9/11. The White House immediately began a campaign of rhetoric following 9/11 that started with former President George Bush who was determined to present "true" Islam as a "religion of peace." That bridge-building campaign probably had an assortment of motives. Perhaps two of many interrelated motives were: 1) to protect innocent Muslims in America from random attacks of retaliation in the immediate post 9/11 environment of fear and rage; and 2) to convince the Islamic world that the United States had no desire to enter into conflict with the voices of moderation that presumably exist within the greater Islamic world.

That same approach has been continued by our current President Barack Obama. The president recently shared his views concerning the proposed Islamic center that would be built just two blocks away from Ground Zero in New York City. This proposal has reinvigorated the simmering polarization mentioned above. For many, the mosque and Islamic complex would reveal the best of America's sense of tolerance and legal fair play; together with American open-mindedness and inclusiveness. For many others, the close proximity of the mosque will be nothing short of an affront to the memory of those who died in the terrorist attacks engineered and planned by Muslims, as Ground Zero has taken on something of the aura of sacred ground. It is also considered to be a "provocation" that common sense dictates against. When carefully articulated, both positions can sound quite convincing. Thus, in addition to the two positions outlined here, there probably exists a large group of Americans who feel torn between these two positions and hence less certain of a definitive stance.

The role of the president, ideally conceived, is to serve as the representative voice of America. That means he want to embody the virtues of American identity at its best, beginning with the noble ideal of being above "partisan politics," and thus affirm his ability to survey the deepest implications of a course of action and its long-term effects on America's commitment to its best ideals and its international image. That ideal was upheld in the president's rather bland statement that, "Muslims have a right to practice their religion as anyone else." In that light, his public comments in favor of the mosque being built near Ground Zero make sense. I am convinced that former President George Bush - or any president for that matter, Democrat or Republican - would have taken the identical stance, whatever their private beliefs or wishes. We have also learned that the President Obama later equivocated by further explaining that his comments were not directed at "the wisdom of such a choice" for the placement of the mosque, but were simply a defense of the Muslim community's "right" to build the mosque where it chooses. That equivocation signaled something of a White House retreat due to the "firestorm" of his initial comments. Political pressure always seems to encroach upon the ideal.

The above is meant to serve as an introduction to a few comments I would like to share concerning the context in which the president's initial comments were made - an iftar dinner at the White House. An iftar dinner, if I understand this correctly, is the dinner that Muslims enjoy following a day-long fast from sunrise to sunset during the month of Ramadan, one of the most sacred times of the year for Muslims. I also learned that former President Bush hosted the same iftar dinner annually (beginning post 9/11?). This is fine. Again, this is the administration's attempt at bridge-building with the Muslim community, together with its assurance that Muslims can take a place within the world of American "religious diversity." My first question is admittedly perhaps a bit superficial, but I wonder if the president hosts a lenten dinner for Christian leaders at the appropriate time of the year? (Let the Orthodox handle the menu for such a lenten dinner!).

What struck me, however, as not only supremely ironic, but as horribly hypocritical, was the make-up of some of the dinner guests before whom he made his comments. I read that there were "representatives" from Saudi Arabia and Indonesia at the iftar dinner, no doubt applauding the president's comments. And I am certain that such representatives had to be invited for political reasons. But, if I am not mistaken, there is not a single church anywhere in Saudi Arabia outside of diplomatic compounds! They are forbidden by intolerant Islamic-generated laws. Saudi Arabia is the home of Wahhabi Islam, a "reformation movement" within Sunni Islam that gained currency in the early 20th c. This is actually an extreme form of Islam that is "hard-core fundamentalist." Again, it is inherently intolerant. There is absolutely no "room" for different religious beliefs or claims to Truth. And though there are churches in Indonesia, Christians there are constantly under siege, persecuted and subject to outbreaks of violence that are conveniently overlooked by the police. I therefore repeat that I detect a definite strain of hypocrisy in the presence of Saudi Arabian and Indonesian "representatives" at a dinner which became the occasion for the president to express America's commitment to toleration and peaceful co-existence. Was the president trying to convey a "lesson" in civil rights to these figures? A more lasting question may be: will American tolerance be eventually emulated as a great national strength; or will it be exploited as a national weakness?

As a footnote, I wanted to share a bit of unpublicized information that I just heard from "a reliable source." The Greek Orthodox church of St. Nicholas - located at Ground Zero - was destroyed in the 9/11 attacks. I was told that to this day, bureaucratic obstacles are still preventing the rebuilding of that church, while the newly-proposed mosque has cleared all local ordinances, zoning qualifications, etc. No further comment required.

Fr. Steven

Friday, August 6, 2010

The Green Feast


Dear Parish Faithful,

I would like to greet everyone on this glorious Feast Day of the Lord's Transfiguration.

We served and celebrated a wonderful Vesperal Liturgy yesterday evening for the Feast. Today, August 6, we continue in the light of that Feast. The truly excellent parish participation and presence contributed greatly to the festal atmosphere and beauty of the Liturgy. In other words, many people came to worship; and so the Feast was a communal event, and not simply a formal obligation dictated by the Church calendar. Blessing the fruit baskets toward the end of the Liturgy is always a joyous rite that is followed by the fellowship of sharing from each other's basket.

Someone remarked to me that the Feast of the Transfiguration is Orthodoxy's "Green Feast." This is an effective and contemporary way of expressing a genuine Orthodox Christian "environmentalism" that is beautifully manifested in the Transfiguration. This Feast anticipates and points toward the glorification of all creation at the end of time. Then, God will be "all in all" and the uncreated light of the Holy Trinity will illuminate the renewed creation that is now "groaning" as it awaits its liberation (ROM. 8). In a mysterious manner, all of creation will dwell in "light unapproachable." It is in the above-mentioned blessing of the fruit that this "cosmological dimension" is revealed, however humbly those colorful fruit baskets appear to our eyes.

Unfortunately, talk of the "environment" has been hopelessly politicized in our public discourse. One's position on the environment has almost become a code word for a particular political/social orientation. If you want to start a heated debate, just mention "global-warming" or "climate change" in front of someone who has a different perspective than your own! Such polarization is deeply regrettable. But no matter where each of us may stand on contemporary environmentalism, surely every Orthodox Christian has some appreciation and sense of responsibility for the creation. We are "stewards" of the world around us, according to Gen. 1. And it is God's creation that is also drawn into the Transfiguration. So this is our "Green Feast," meaning that we rejoice in the created realm, we assume responsibility for its proper care, and we anticipate the God-chosen time when "the creation itself will be set free from its bondage to decay and obtain the glorious liberty of the children of God." (ROM. 8:21)

In Christ,

Fr. Steven

Wednesday, August 4, 2010

How is it Possible?


Dear Parish Faithful,

Tomorrow evening we will celebrate the Great Feast of the Transfiguration of the Lord with a Vesperal Liturgy (6:00 p.m.). Following the Liturgy, we will bless the traditional fruit baskets. So please remember to bring them along tomorrow. The Feast is on August 6, but as we often do, we will serve the Vesperal Liturgy to allow for more parish participation. Hopefully, many of you will be here for this remarkable Feast, a Feast that reveals divine Beauty, as it reveals Truth and Goodness. Christ ascends Mt. Tabor, is transfigured in "unapproachable light," and reveals His true nature as the Son of God incarnate to His overwhelmed disciples. Christ anticipates His own resurrection and the beauty of the "world to come" that will be bathed in the eternal and uncreated light of the Triune God.

This is a Feast to look forward to. As Orthodox Christians, we are blessed with the inclusion of the Transfiguration in the annual liturgical cycle of the Twelve Great Feast Days. This is not the case in other churches, where it tends to be neglected. But that brings to mind an interesting personal reminiscence I once heard from a parishioner. Someone once told me of how devoted her mother was to Christ, and how much she enjoyed the feast of the Transfiguration as celebrated in her church for the very reasons we make so much of it as Orthodox, even though she herself was not Orthodox. What stayed in my mind were her words - spoken with a definite sadness, I was told - when the day of the Transfiguration's celebration came around: "Today is the Transfiguration and no one cares!" How is it possible "not to care" when we can actually celebrate Jesus shining with light brighter than the sun on the mount? How is it possible "not to care" when we can carry our fruit to church to be blessed as a sign of the transfiguration of the material world in "the life of the world to come?" How is it possible "not to care" when all will be prepared for the celebration of the Feast and we simply have to bring our tired and over-heated bodies to the church for the spiritual renewal that awaits us there?

Bearing such rhetorical questions in mind, I look forward to a church full of "caring" parishioners who anticipate this "Feast of Divine Beauty" as an event not to be missed if at all possible.

In Christ,

Fr. Steven